Black and white star-shaped design with a black circle in the center.
Black and white star-shaped graphic with a circular center.

Denial Appeals and A/R Recovery

Written by Corey Blackburn, DPM, Founder

Prairie Specialty Billing works denied claims and aging accounts receivable for practices that already have a biller, and for practices that want full-service billing. We check claims before they go out, appeal denials, and follow balances that have not been paid.

What does Prairie take on?

We take pre-submission claim checks, denial appeals, aging accounts receivable, payment posting, and patient statements. Patients receive up to three statements. After those statements and soft collection attempts, we work with the collection agency the practice prefers. A practice can ask for this work without sending every new claim to us.

What does aging mean?

Aging is how long a balance has gone unpaid. Practices usually group balances at 30, 60, 90, and 120 days and older. Older balances are harder to collect because filing limits, payer records, and patient contact all get worse with time. Those day labels are buckets. They are not a recovery rate.

How does Prairie work an aging report?

We start with the report your practice already has. Nobody needs to switch software first. Then we sort it, roughly in this order:

  1. Claims close to a filing or appeal deadline. A balance that can still be fixed this month comes ahead of a bigger one that can wait.

  2. Larger balances in the 60- and 90-day buckets. They still have time left, and there is usually a reason on file.

  3. Claims with no response at all. No payment and no denial often means the payer never accepted the claim. A call or a portal check settles it.

  4. Small balances spread across many patients. These get worked in batches.

Every claim ends up with a next step and a date: a corrected claim, an appeal, a call to the payer, a patient statement, or a write-off for the practice to approve. A balance with no next step is how a 60-day claim turns into a 180-day claim.

What does the denial reason code tell you?

Every denial comes back with a reason code on the remittance, and the code decides the fix. A few we see often:

  • CO-16: the claim is missing information or has a billing error. This is usually fixed with a corrected claim, not an appeal.

  • CO-197: no prior authorization on file. Sometimes the authorization exists and was never attached. Sometimes it was never requested.

  • CO-22: the payer thinks another plan should pay first. The patient's coverage has to be updated before anything is sent again.

  • CO-29: the filing limit has passed. Unless you can show the claim was filed on time, for example with a clearinghouse acceptance report, this one is usually lost.

  • CO-50: the payer does not consider the service medically necessary. This is a real appeal, and it needs the visit note.

Sending the same claim again without changing anything rarely works. Most payers deny it as a duplicate.

Should a denied claim be appealed or corrected?

If the claim had a mistake, such as a wrong modifier, a missing NPI, or an old policy number, we fix it and send a corrected claim. If the claim was right and the payer disagrees, we appeal. A good appeal points to the visit note and to the payer's own policy. It does not argue in general terms. For Medicare, the first level of appeal, called a redetermination, has to be requested within 120 days of receiving the initial decision.

What does Prairie need to start?

  • Your current A/R aging report, by payer and by patient

  • Remittances or EOBs for the claims in question

  • Access to your payer portals and clearinghouse, or someone who can pull reports for us

  • Visit notes for anything going to appeal

  • Your fee schedule and any payer contracts you have on file

If some of this is missing, we can still start. We will tell you which balances we cannot work without it.

When is a balance not worth chasing?

Some balances cost more to work than they will bring in. Others are past every deadline. We flag these instead of quietly working them, and the practice decides whether to write them off. That decision stays with you.

What happens to old A/R when you change billing companies?

The prior company’s open claims do not move on their own. Someone has to list what is unpaid, what was denied, what is still pending, and what was never submitted, then decide who will work each group. Prairie can work that older inventory. We do not quote a percentage recovered.

Timely filing

Medicare fee-for-service claims generally must be filed no later than one calendar year after the date of service. A claim denied because it was late is not appealed the way a medical-necessity denial is. Other payers set their own limits. We check the limit before spending time on a balance that can no longer be billed.

A recovery percentage and a turnaround time for old accounts receivable are not stated here. Most consultations are scheduled within two business days.